Digital Identity Without Control Is Surveillance—Not Privacy

By Lisa Moynihan, Head of Operations & Communications, DCID DAO Foundation

‍

Introduction: The Illusion of Privacy

In today’s digital landscape, most people assume they have control over their online

identity. After all, they log in, choose settings, and occasionally click “accept” on a privacy

policy. But that sense of control is largely an illusion. In practice, digital identity is fractured

across platforms, owned by centralized entities, and managed according to opaque rules

that prioritize monetization over privacy.

This isn’t just an issue of convenience—it’s a crisis of control. When identity is managed by

third parties and manipulated without the user’s understanding or ability to intervene,

we’re not talking about privacy anymore. We’re talking about surveillance.

Surveillance by Design

Today’s internet wasn’t built with consent at the core. Instead, it was built on centralized

platforms designed to track, collect, and exploit user data for profit. From device IDs to

login credentials and behavioral signals, everything becomes part of a massive digital

profile that’s monetized in the background. Consent, where it’s even requested, is often

buried in legalese, presented as a one-time checkbox, and never revisited.

Once data is collected, users rarely know where it goes, who uses it, or how long it’s kept.

Consent becomes meaningless when it cannot be modified or revoked. The very

architecture of today’s digital identity systems enables persistent monitoring—instead of

user empowerment. And when platforms quietly scrape, score, and share your identity, the

line between convenience and exploitation becomes impossible to ignore.

The Cost of Losing Control

This lack of control isn’t just frustrating—it’s dangerous. When users cannot manage their

identity and consent, they are vulnerable to real-world harm. Personal health data from

fitness apps get used to push unverified supplements. Facial recognition images from

social platforms are sold to law enforcement or foreign surveillance firms. Location data is

commodified and used for political targeting or predictive behavioral modeling. Even credit

scores and insurance decisions can be influenced by behind-the-scenes profiling based

on your digital footprint.

What’s more, users are often unaware this is happening until it’s too late. Their data

continues to work for others, long after it was initially given, often with no recourse or

visibility. This silent erosion of privacy is the byproduct of systems that prioritize data

extraction over transparency and control.

What True Privacy Requires

Privacy today demands more than a disclaimer or a pop-up banner. It requires identity

systems that treat users as decision-makers, not data sources. Real privacy starts with

user ownership of identity—where consent is not static, but flexible, responsive, and

revocable.

For digital identity to truly serve individuals, it must be portable across platforms,

transparent in its use, and dynamic in its permissions. People should be able to grant

consent for specific use cases, withdraw it at will, and trust that their identity isn’t being

used in ways they didn’t authorize.

Digital identity without this kind of control isn’t privacy. It’s manipulation dressed up as

access. And it’s long past time we called it what it is.

DCID: Identity on Your Terms

The Digital Consent Identity (DCID) standard was created to change this dynamic. Instead

of reinforcing platform control, DCID empowers users to manage their identity across the

internet—on their terms. Designed as an open, user-first framework, DCID enables

individuals to carry their digital identity with them from site to site, maintaining agency and

visibility the entire way.

With DCID, consent isn’t a one-and-done event—it’s programmable, contextual, and

revocable at any time. If someone wants to share their health data with an app for 30 days,

they can do exactly that—and then revoke access without needing legal intervention. If

location sharing is necessary during a trip, it can expire automatically. These are the real -

world applications of programmable consent, and they are made possible through DCID

infrastructure.

Unlike legacy systems built for platform analytics, DCID is built for people. It ensures that

identity is not something extracted—but something protected and controlled.

Rethinking Identity Infrastructure

As governments and enterprises accelerate the shift toward digital credentials, digital

wallets, and online verification, we are at a fork in the road. The world can either adopt

systems that replicate surveillance in a new wrapper—or build a new standard rooted in

autonomy and trust.

DCID doesn’t compete with regulation—it complements and exceeds it. By offering a

functional, scalable model ahead of legislation, DCID provides both public and private

institutions with a trustworthy framework they can adopt and build upon. It shifts the

paradigm from reactive compliance to proactive trust. The infrastructure is already here.

What’s needed now is the will to implement it.

Conclusion: Control Is the Core of Privacy

Privacy is not a feature to toggle—it’s a fundamental design principle. And in a world where

digital identity governs access to services, opportunities, and freedoms, whoever controls

your identity ultimately controls your life.

Surveillance thrives in systems where users are silent and uninformed. But consent-based

identity—rooted in transparency, control, and accountability—offers a different future.

One where users aren't just visible, but powerful. One where digital infrastructure respects

autonomy and builds trust by default. DCID meets and exceeds today’s regulatory

expectations, but its deeper mission is to lead with user trust and set a new global

standard for privacy in the digital age.

About the Author

Lisa Moynihan is the Head of Operations & Communications at the DCID DAO Foundation,

the governance body behind the Digital Consent Identity standard. She leads the

Foundation’s strategy, partnerships, and global messaging efforts focused on redefining

identity and consent for a decentralized internet.

Media Inquiries

For interviews, commentary, or speaking engagements, please contact Lisa Moynihan at

Lisa@dcidfoundation.org.

‍